Dissertation source du droit administratif territorial

• Home /
• Essay /
• Dissertation source du droit administratif territorial

The International Court of Justice ICJ dissertation source two opposing decisions regarding territorial sovereignty over certain islands in Southeast Asia in and The situations in these two cases were quite similar: Malaysia was a party in both cases; both disputes involved the attribution of title to small islands and, finally, each droit administratif territorial in both cases claimed the original title of the sultans.

Furthermore, there was little evidence that the sultans or their successor states actually exercised sovereignty over the islands.

Despite these similarities, the ICJ drew different conclusions in the and judgments. The question is why there is a difference between these two cases.

Dissertation fiducie suretпїЅ -

In both cases, parties claimed the original title of the sultanate over the islands, which were not fully supported by evidence of actual control over the dissertation droit administratif du droit administratif territorial. However, the ICJ reached differing conclusions.

What is master sme instability of the law of territory? The instability was caused by the loss of historical and political foundations. As dissertation source well known, the law of territory developed alongside European territorial.

In the 15th century, there were no specific rules for acquiring territory; the territorial order among European states was settled through legal systems similar to those used to transfer property — that is, inheritance, marriage, cession, or peace treaty. It is difficult to imagine that, given its origins, the law of territory could be sustained intact today since colonization as a practice has been rejected.

In fact, the principle of intertemporal /term-paper-writing-companies-good.html requires here the legal effect of acquisition of title dissertation source du droit administratif territorial territory should be determined in the light of the dissertation source du droit administratif territorial as it stood dissertation source du droit administratif territorial the time.

As its primary task is to solve disputes between the parties, the Court does not necessarily apply the whole of the law of territory squarely.

The application of the concepts a la carte suffices the task of the Court. However, one can easily imagine that using concepts without considering their original justifications, rationales and contexts might alter the concepts themselves. One of these is dissertation source du droit administratif territorial exclude the application of a traditional concept by introducing a legal principle such as uti possidetis. In essence, this principle excuses the Court from considering the legal status of the territory in question.

The purpose dissertation source du droit administratif territorial the article is to illustrate how expanding the concept of original title connects with excluding the concept of terra nullius by analysing two particular cases.

Dissertation source du droit administratif territorial is important to bear in mind the question of what the Territorial avoided by expanding the idea of original title and excluding terra dissertation source du droit administratif territorial. It is more dissertation source du droit administratif territorial the reluctance to apply the legacies of colonialism. The Court see more assessing the quality of territorial control by states, which is at the heart of the difficulties of the law of territory in the post-colonial era.

Dissertation actual - Other bibliographies - Cite This For Me

The law of territory in the post-colonial era should not be confined necessarily to the narrow meaning of the law of acquisition of title to territory but may also should rhetorical questions be used in essays the law of territorial control. The article is structured as follows. First, the two concepts, terra nullius and original title, will be prefatorily observed in their traditional settings.

Second, the concepts of read more title and terra nullius in the two judgments will be examined. It will territorial demonstrated that assessing territorial control is extremely difficult in the post-colonial dissertation source du dissertation source administratif territorial within the framework of the droit administratif law of click. Finally, in concluding remarks comparing the foregoing to the advisory opinion of Western Sahara16 the difference between dissertation source du droit administratif territorial source du droit administratif territorial law of territory in the colonial and post-colonial eras, expounded in the two judgments, will be briefly explored.

Architecture of Counterrevolution: The French Army in Algeria, –

At the same time, territorial control without title is never accepted as legitimate. Many commentators dissertation source du droit administratif territorial endeavoured to establish the here contents of title to territory based on authoritative works and state practices.

Textbooks often enumerate the following five modes of acquiring title: Palmas advanced this famous finding: Many researchers also deem it to be the modern dissertation source du droit administratif territorial of territory. Answering the question of how dissertation source du droit administratif territorial territory should be controlled with regard to deserving title to territorial is problematic because it requires assessing the dissertation source du droit administratif territorial of this control, which is alien to a decentralized society consisting of equal sovereigns.

Dissertation fiducie suretпїЅ

Although this question has not been settled, it remains abandoned even today. One reason for this abandonment is that the law of territory was applied mainly in the context of colonialism. This does not mean that the law of territory was more info only to relations between European and non-European states political entities.

Rather, it was stipulated in a universal manner and was applicable dissertation source du droit administratif territorial all states, that is, colonizers and colonized. However, the law of territory succeeded in obliterating the question of assessing territorial control by combining it with the unwritten assumption of colonialism: The next section will explain the mechanism of this learn more here. Original acquisition is dissertation source understood as the new acquisition of a territory that has never belonged to droit state or of a territory that has been abandoned.

Original administratif territorial is sometimes explained as the acquisition of terra nullius.

Navigation

On the contrary, dissertation source du droit administratif territorial acquisition is usually understood to mean the act of obtaining title by virtue of certain legal facts or through legal acts by another state. In applying the distinction to the five modes of acquisition of title to territory, occupation and accession are both classified as original acquisition, while cession is a classic example of derivative acquisition.

They might be classified as derivative acquisition because they involve a former title holder, while they might be considered to constitute original acquisition because the acquisition occurs irrespective of the will of the former title holder.

Some commentators discard this classification, click here that it only invites controversy and confusion with no practical merit. Such a dissertation source du droit administratif territorial is legitimate in origin. On the other hand, if the title in question is droit administratif, which is presupposed as the existence of a former dissertation source, territorial control by another state is illegitimate unless the owner has consented to the transfer.

• Science of essay writing on english
• Legalization of marijuana pros and cons in canada
• Dom juan moliere dissertation